10 Tips for Winning as a Criminal in Who Did It?
Published: June 2026 ยท 5 min read
Playing as a criminal in Who Did It? is one of the most exciting roles in the game. You know who you are and who your fellow criminals are, and you must deceive everyone else. Here are 10 proven strategies to help you survive.
1. Know Your Character
Read your character's profession and relationship carefully. The best lies are built on truth. Use your character's details to explain your presence and actions naturally.
2. Don't Be Too Quiet or Too Loud
Both extremes attract attention. Match the energy of other players. Participate naturally in discussions without overcompensating.
3. Accuse Selectively
Pointing fingers too early makes you look desperate. Wait until a clue reasonably implicates someone else. Build your case gradually.
4. Use the Clues to Your Advantage
Every clue has two interpretations. As a criminal, champion the misleading interpretation. Argue why the clue points to someone else.
5. Build Alliances with Innocent Players
Agree with investigators when they make good points. Build trust early so they are less likely to suspect you later.
6. Watch Voting Patterns
Pay attention to who votes for whom. Encourage rifts between investigators. Divide and conquer.
7. Defend Fellow Criminals Carefully
Defending another criminal too strongly exposes both. Redirect suspicion subtly instead of making direct defenses.
8. Have a Story Prepared
When asked what happened, have a plausible theory ready that connects the story and clues without implicating you or your fellow criminals.
9. Use the Discussion Timer
If discussion goes against you, redirect the conversation. Ask questions and create confusion to prevent consensus against you.
10. Accept Elimination with Grace
If eliminated, stay neutral. Your reaction can influence remaining players. A calm elimination helps your team.
Remember: Who Did It? is about fun and mystery. Play fair, be creative, and enjoy the suspense. Check out our hosting guide and clue categories guide.